Lay Preacher Proclamation - a gift of the worldwide church
Rev. Bradn Buerkle
The Church’s witness to the Good News of Jesus Christ is enriched when the gifts of the whole community are recognized, nurtured, and put to use. Across the world, churches are actively exploring how laypeople can take on a greater role in the life and mission of their congregations. This is not simply a practical response to changing circumstances (including a shortage of professional ministers), but an opportunity to rediscover the richness of the Church’s calling and the many ways in which God equips people for service.
Preaching is one important expression of this shared calling. For Lutherans, the proclamation of the Good News in worship has always been of unsurpassed importance. Interpreting God’s Word in ways that nurture faith in Christ and encourage discipleship is essential to the Church’s mission. When laypeople are equipped to preach, congregations can benefit from a wider range of voices, experiences, and perspectives through which the Gospel speaks to the realities of everyday life.
We can ground the theology of such exploration in Martin Luther’s teaching on the “priesthood of all believers,” which emphasizes the equality of all Christians before God through baptism. For Luther, the distinction between clergy and laity was not an inherent difference in spiritual status: all Christians can be instruments of God’s grace to one another. This was a radical position for his time. While some contemporaries rejected it, others interpreted it to mean that every baptized person had the right to preach. Luther, however, feared that this could lead to disorder and, more seriously, to a distortion of the Gospel. The Wittenberg reformers therefore distinguished between the universal priesthood of all believers and the call to public ministry. The Augsburg Confession holds these principles together: preaching is essential to the Church (CA V), but the Gospel must also be taught rightly and in good order (CA VII, XIV).
These principles remain useful today. Lutheran churches share a commitment to Gospel proclamation, but differ in the structures they use to ensure sound teaching and orderly practice. Within the EKD, there is no standardized model for the training, commissioning and support of lay preachers and lay ministers. Similarly, ELM’s partner churches have developed their own rules, processes and/or traditions for determining when and where laypeople may preach. In all chuches, the different training and support models reflect both local needs and an (implicit or explicit) New Testament understanding of spiritual gifts - an approach acknowledges our mutual importance to one another in the Body of Christ without necessitating identical roles. Recognizing these gifts requires both personal discernment (“inner call”) and communal affirmation (“external call”), a commitment of the individual to developing one’s gifts for the good of the community, together with a commitment of the community of faith to provide a space and framework for those gifts to be put to use.
This theology offers a foundation for responding to the rapid decline of what once seemed, in many churches, to be a stable system of congregational life centered on professional pastors. Although our current situation may feel unprecedented, we can take comfort in the fact that the church has faced such challenges before - both in our recent past (e.g., during the clergy shortage in Germany during and between the two world wars) and at the church’s very beginnings (long before church offices or professional training took their modern forms.) As we strive for a sustainable future, it is surprising how often we can find wisdom in the past.
As a Church that is always reforming, we can find wisdom in both our history and in the diversity of practices we see among global partners. As siblings in the worldwide Church, we can learn a great deal from one another, because our diversity is a source of richness for us all. Together we can seek answers to such questions as: What can reasonably be expected of volunteer preachers, and how can they be supported? Which training methods work best when finances are limited, learning technologies are not equally accessible, and volunteers face competing demands on their time? What roles should congregations, mentors, and church structures play in accompanying and authorizing lay preachers? Encountering different approaches to lay ministry can broaden our understanding and strengthen our own practice.
ELM has a unique opportunity to bring partner churches together for mutual learning on these and related questions. In doing so, we continue a longstanding commitment to equipping laypeople, from the days of Harms to the present, and affirm that everyone has a valuable contribution to make to discovering fresh ways of communicating the timeless Good News of Jesus Christ in today’s world. Rather than viewing lay preachers primarily through the lens of what the Church lacks, we can celebrate what God has already given: a community richly gifted by the Holy Spirit and called to share in the witnessing to Christ together.